| 1 | Mariano Rivera | BBWAA | 425 | 425 | 319 | Inducted |
| 2 | Roy Halladay | BBWAA | 363 | 425 | 319 | Inducted |
| 3 | Edgar Martinez | BBWAA | 363 | 425 | 319 | Inducted |
| 4 | Mike Mussina | BBWAA | 326 | 425 | 319 | Inducted |
| 5 | Curt Schilling | BBWAA | 259 | 425 | 319 | |
| 6 | Roger Clemens | BBWAA | 253 | 425 | 319 | |
| 7 | Barry Bonds | BBWAA | 251 | 425 | 319 | |
| 8 | Larry Walker | BBWAA | 232 | 425 | 319 | |
| 9 | Omar Vizquel | BBWAA | 182 | 425 | 319 | |
| 10 | Fred McGriff | BBWAA | 169 | 425 | 319 | |
| 11 | Manny Ramirez | BBWAA | 97 | 425 | 319 | |
| 12 | Jeff Kent | BBWAA | 77 | 425 | 319 | |
| 13 | Scott Rolen | BBWAA | 73 | 425 | 319 | |
| 14 | Billy Wagner | BBWAA | 71 | 425 | 319 | |
| 15 | Todd Helton | BBWAA | 70 | 425 | 319 | |
| 16 | Gary Sheffield | BBWAA | 58 | 425 | 319 | |
| 17 | Andy Pettitte | BBWAA | 42 | 425 | 319 | |
| 18 | Sammy Sosa | BBWAA | 36 | 425 | 319 | |
| 19 | Andruw Jones | BBWAA | 32 | 425 | 319 | |
| 20 | Lee Smith | Veterans - Today's Game Era | 16 | 16 | 12 | Inducted |
| 21 | Harold Baines | Veterans - Today's Game Era | 12 | 16 | 12 | Inducted |
| 22 | Lou Piniella | Veterans - Today's Game Era | 11 | 16 | 12 | |
| 23 | Michael Young | BBWAA | 9 | 425 | 319 | |
| 24 | Miguel Tejada | BBWAA | 5 | 425 | 319 | |
| 25 | Lance Berkman | BBWAA | 5 | 425 | 319 | |
| 26 | Roy Oswalt | BBWAA | 4 | 425 | 319 | |
| 27 | Placido Polanco | BBWAA | 2 | 425 | 319 | |
| 28 | Darren Oliver | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 29 | Juan Pierre | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 30 | Derek Lowe | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 31 | Ted Lilly | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 32 | Travis Hafner | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 33 | Jon Garland | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 34 | Freddy Garcia | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 35 | Jason Bay | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 36 | Vernon Wells | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 37 | Kevin Youkilis | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 38 | Rick Ankiel | BBWAA | 0 | 425 | 319 | |
| 39 | Albert Belle | Veterans - Today's Game Era | | 16 | 12 | |
| 40 | Charlie Manuel | Veterans - Today's Game Era | | 16 | 12 | |
| 41 | Davey Johnson | Veterans - Today's Game Era | | 16 | 12 | |
| 42 | Orel Hershiser | Veterans - Today's Game Era | | 16 | 12 | |
| 43 | Will Clark | Veterans - Today's Game Era | | 16 | 12 | |
| 44 | George Steinbrenner | Veterans - Today's Game Era | | 16 | 12 | |
| 45 | Joe Carter | Veterans - Today's Game Era | | 16 | 12 | |